According to the sec, i2 favored upfront recognition of software license revenue, which is accepted under generally accepted accounting principals gaap. Historically, i2 favored upfront recognition of software license revenue, purportedly in accordance with generally accepted accounting principals gaap. However, i2 knew or should have known that immediate recognition of revenue was unsuitable for a number of i2s software licenses because they required long and involved implementation and. Jda software app license sales stall in q2 it jungle. Lawson software reversed a license free fall showing growth in q3 22. For an updated look at how revenue composition impacts valuation, request the understanding quality of revenue whitepaper, published 2018.
However, as i2 knew or was reckless in not knowing, immediate recognition of revenue was inappropriate for some of i2 s software licenses because they required lengthy and intense. Executive summary statement of position sop 972 provides guidance on applying gaap in recognizing revenue from software and softwarerelated transactions. Accounting for externaluse software development costs in. At a former company with this model and a mature customer base our annual revenues broke down roughly 20% license, 35% pro services, and 45% maintenance.
Since the business model has changed, so has the accounting and software revenue recognition rules. The two companies said that the combined revenue of i2 and aspect would make the merged company the largest provider of software and. Software license revenues are recognized upon shipment, provided fees are fixed and determinable and collection is probable. I2 and rightworks merger goes forward, amid market turmoil. They told me that they will send me quarterly reports. Common examples are adobe creative suite, quickbooks, microsoft windows home. Nov 04, 1996 irving a 195% thirdquarter revenue increase at i2 technologies inc.
Detailed rules on software license revenue recognition bi101. Zd net b2b software vendors seek new revenue source. Onpremise vendors showing gains in eps despite revenue drops see figure 2. The new revenue standards asc 606 and ifrs 15, revenue from contracts with customers replace industryspecific. Revenue increased slightly in q4, and overall 2011 was a good year for the retail and supply chain software pillar. On july 21, 2003, following an internal investigation, i2 restated its financial statements for the restatement period. If a percentage is listed in the license royalty column e. Jdas today announced financial results for the third quarter ended september 30, 2008. Former i2 technologies chief executive officer gregory a. Jul 27, 2010 jda software announces second quarter 2010 results.
Companies of similar size in the same market may have quite different valuations based. The new revenue standards asc 606 and ifrs 15, revenue from. Youre right about jde, though they were a special case. Bim35805 explains that the treatment of a single payment for a software licence as capital expenditure or revenue depends on the role in economic terms that the software plays in the business. I am about to license software to a european company. Today, most software is at least customized to fit the needs of customers and it is also sold under a subscription model that grants access as required, rather than the perpetual license which grants unlimited access to the software in perpetuity. Even though bradys visionary approach led to products of increased complexity that required extensive adaptation to meet customer needs, i2 clung to its revenue recognition model favoring upfront recognition of software license revenue. Jdes as400 base provided an unusual ratio of service to license revenue that skewed jdes revenues even in 97. We have many options for controlling the entrance to parking lots or garages and for collecting money, credentials proxsmart cardrfid or parking validations.
Kmart sues i2 over software dallas business journal. These transactions involved thirdparty purchases of software licenses from i2, from which i2 recognized revenue immediately, in exchange for i2 s agreement to purchase from the other parties in the future a comparable amount of products or services. Ibm i2 analysts notebook arms analysts with multidimensional visual analysis capabilities so they can. As technology becomes further entrenched in consumer and enterprise products, companies outside of the traditional software. Analysts following software maker i2 repeatedly have had. These transactions involved thirdparty purchases of software licenses from i2, with i2 recognizing the revenue immediately, in exchange for i2 s agreement to purchase from the other parties in the future a comparable amount of products or services. Subscription revenue decline mars jda financial report it. Jda has not finalized its financial results for q4 2011, but.
We closed 54 new software deals in the quarter compared to 68 in the second. Let us know and well get you a competitive custom quote. Income earned by a company for allowing its ed or patented material to be used by another company. A boy and his atom common public licenseibm public license customer. Careful planning can aid in the analysis of which costs to. Software license arrangements can be organized as a hosting arrangement, saas, a hybrid of both hosting and saas, or direct delivery to the customerall of which have different implications for the application of each of the five steps of the new revenue recognition model. Apr 26, 2004 i2 s revenue fell on both a sequential and a yearly basis in q1 2004. A customer is expected to buy an entirely new software license every. Accounting for externaluse software development costs in an. The sop provides instruction on recognition for licensing, selling, leasing or otherwise marketing software. Jda software reports record ebitda and third quarter.
Software companies that close their doors have nothing useful to sell. Irving a 195% thirdquarter revenue increase at i2 technologies inc. Oracle business intelligence applications global price list. Despite reported losses, i2 had its best quarter morningstar. Additional considerations in the determination of whether software is more than incidental 26 25. For new sales, maintenance was 1820% of license revenue and implementation services roughly equaled license revenue. Jul 28, 2010 as a percentage of total revenue, this was a very large deal that significantly impacted total company margins for 2009.
Oracle business intelligence applications standalone the product below is a standalone business intelligence application and does not work in conjunction with the oracle business intelligence application product family. Gartner says worldwide scm new license software revenue. Examples of disclosures made by companies that have applied sop 972 to recognize revenue 22 22. Subscription revenue decline mars jda financial report. Despite shrinking revenue during the past quarter, growing software license sales and rising earnings have supply chain management applications vendor i2 technologies inc. Lancaster and i2 s sales force to aggressively market i2 s software. Please check the oracle business intelligence applications price list supplement for prerequisite product information. The new emphasis on recurring revenue represents a shift because investors so far have rewarded companies like ariba and i2 because of revenue from upfront licensing fees. Jda software reports record ebitda and third quarter software.
Existing customers generated 62 percent of i2 s license revenue. Although sap now holds the leadership position in the market, it only increased its market share 1. This publication reflects implementation developments since issuance of the standards and highlights considerations relevant in evaluating the. Brewers statements regarding license revenue growth from i2 products and the progress. Software companies continue to analyze the impact of the new revenue standard on their contracts, accounting policies, and financial statements. Existing customers generated 62 percent of i2s license revenue. The increase in number of components of a single contract may result in earlier recognition of revenue for software companies compared to the timing under prior revenue recognition rules. Jda softwares 4thqtr profit falls on charges cbs news. Jun 09, 2004 i2 also improperly recorded software license revenue from four nonmonetary, or barter, transactions. A software licensing arrangement refers to an arrangement in which a software license is transferred to the customer in accordance with paragraph 606105554a. Deciding which externaluse software development costs can be capitalized in an agile project environment involves a certain amount of judgment. Jan 16, 2012 jda software powered its way through 2011 to post decent financial numbers despite the legal battles it fought with oracle over patent infringements and a lawsuit it inherited with the acquisition of i2 in august 2010. However, as i2 knew or was reckless in not knowing, immediate recognition of revenue was inappropriate for some of i2s software licenses because they required lengthy and intense.
According to sab 104 and software license revenue recognition rules, revenue for both perpetual and time based licenses can be recognized when the licenses are delivered as long as a firm has satisfied the following rules. While this is a useful metric for understanding valuation ranges, it also can be misleading. Im assuming your model is an upfront license with annual maintenance. Ibm industry solutions i2 analyst\s notebook gemini. In many cases, the specific facts and circumstances surrounding the type of software being developed will drive the treatment of costs. Itwo today announced the following results for the third quarter of 2009. Revenue recognition within the software industry has historically been highly complex with much industryspecific guidance. After a continual, spectacular rise in revenues during the 1990s, i2 sales. I2 technologies is a fullservice supply chain management company providing. Stephen taub former i2 technologies chief executive officer gregory a. Jda software announces second quarter 2010 results. In contrast, saas arrangement refers to an arrangement that, even if the contract states that a license to software is conveyed, a license does not exist in accordance with. New revenue guidance implementation in the software industry.
Software pushes i2 revenues almost 200% over last year. Brewers statements regarding license revenue growth from i2. Jda software announces second quarter 2010 results business. Software revenue recognition rules for subscription. Jun 11, 2004 according to the sec, i2 favored upfront recognition of software license revenue, which is accepted under generally accepted accounting principals gaap. Revenue increased slightly in q4, and overall 2011 was a good year for the retail and supply chain software. The effective date for the new standard is periods beginning after dec.
1215 464 758 1411 1259 507 1316 1417 1156 887 414 1205 828 1050 1166 735 466 1291 85 906 1475 1315 443 660 258 925 405 215 1285 125 212 370 296 1111 1231